They make the Mind Peering Peppermints and are able to read each other's minds. Mama P tells the girls to be careful with the Livonian peppermint oil, as it is very rare and her only bottle. Mama P gives them the spices, and Jake walks in not knowing Mama P is helping them, which makes it However, they need Galifrazian Syrup and Livonian Peppermint Oil, which they must get from Mama P. In order to make sure they can trust Mama P, they decide to make Mind Peering Peppermints so they can read into Grandma Quinn's mind. The next morning, Kelly thinks Mama P is telling the truth, while Hannah thinks she is lying. Mama P explains she was desperate to undo her curse, but the book no longer works for her. The girls don't believe her, especially after she stole the cookbook. But she does say she will help the girls reverse the curse. Mama P says that she doesn't believe even Gina could be capable of doing that.

Mama P hasn't been able to leave Saffron Falls since. When Mama P tried to stop her, Gina cursed her. When Kelly asks what happened, as the three of them are clearly apart, Mama P says that Gina couldn't handle the magic, and used it for her personal gains. The three swore the book would never come between them.

The Traveler warns them of the magic, saying they'd be closer together, or driven apart. When they took a field trip into the Cedros Forest, they met the Traveler who gave them the book. It changed after the cookbook came into their lives. Mama P says that she had two best friends, Becky and Gina. Darbie asks if they could take some cookies home to help Kelly's parents, and she agrees.

Mama P explains she sent the cocoa nibs over to lessen the effect of the Cedronian Vanilla they bought. Afterwards, the girls start bombarding Mama P with questions. The girls hesitantly eat the cookies after Mama P explains what they're for. Mama P makes them cookies with Merwaldian White Cocoa Nibs to reverse the spell the girls were under. She tells the girls that she knows what they need, and offers them to have a seat a table. The girls try to run from Mama P, but she locks the door before they get the chance. The magic leads to surprises at home, and they come away with more questions than answers. her memory of magic has been erased.After the Girls learn more of the book's secret history from an unexpected ally, they cook Mind Peering Peppermints to learn who cursed Grandma. That evening, Becky meets the girls in their trailer. Jake and Gina ask a blonde girl that is working with Kelly at Mama P's if she remembers how they met. All three perspectives involved a blonde girl who was also there. Jake and Gina go to Mama P's to ask her if she remembers how the three girls met. Jake asks Terri for the same story, from her perspective, to discover how the girls all met. Gina asks Hannah's sister to recall the first time the three girls met. They see a note in the book about how to return their memories, by going back to what started it all. They discover that in order to remember magic, the girls had to forget something, which ended up being their friendship. Meanwhile, Jake goes to Gina to ask for help with getting the girls' memories back. Becky immediately calls Kelly leaving a message on her phone about a box, and a key to magic. As she is leaving, Becky discovers a photo and asks Laura who it is. Laura tells Becky that the family moved away, after having a very hard life, wanting a clean slate. Laura invites Becky in to talk about the family that asked her to sell some of her things. Grandma Becky goes to Laura P's house, the woman to sold the ornate box to her store. They all remember doing magic, but they believe they cooked it all alone. Jake and Darbie talk and Jake discovers that Darbie has also lost her memory of her friendship with Hannah and Kelly. Hannah seems to have also lost all memories of her friendship with Kelly and Darbie. Later, at school, Kelly seems to have lost the memory that she and Darbie are best friends. The girls say 'magic' as the memory they want to preserve, before they bite into their blueberry preserve topped toast. Darbie takes charge, disseminating the tasks to each of the girls. The girls find a recipe for 'Preserve a Memory Fruit Preserves' and decide to make it. other names on the list include Becky, Gina, Kelly, Hannah, and Darbie. Someone has been crossing off names in a book: RJ, Noelle Jasper, Mama P. The girls ask Jake to be their plan B, in case they get cursed and lose their memories of magic, too. The downside is that they forget their friendship and ever meeting. In order to protect themselves, the trio cooks a spell to help them remember magic forever.

Just add magic cast young mama p